- Rating:





A rhythm game’s tracklist is its greatest asset. It needs to not only appeal to varied taste and musical preference, but it also needs to feature instrumentation that translates into a challenging and fun experience for players.
Guitar Hero for the iPhone includes six tracks.
It’s with only six tracks that Activision hopes to appeal to all App Store customers. EA’s iPhone adaptation of Rock Band features a 30-song tracklist, which covers several genres. Guitar Hero, on the other hand, includes two classic rock songs, two modern (-ish) alternative tracks, and two pop-punk songs. Let’s look over them.
The Rolling Stones’ “Paint It Black,” in addition to being one of the best songs the band recorded over its 200-year history, was a standout in Guitar Hero III’s tracklist, and is still fun to play. The guitar charting is varied and challenging — the bass chart is less so, but it’s still enjoyable.
The White Stripes’ “Seven Nation Army” was another excellent choice for the game. It has an iconic bass line, features interesting guitar work throughout, and — most importantly — it holds up well to repeat listenings.
Weezer’s “Say It Ain’t So” belongs to a weird little category of songs that I personally like, but never want to hear again. This list also includes Faith No More’s “Epic,” Foo Fighters’ “Learn to Fly” and a handful of other tracks that wore out their welcome after being endlessly repeated in the original Rock Band. It’s not a bad song, and the guitar portion is actually pretty catchy. I’m just tired of hearing it.
The same can be said of Queen’s “We Are the Champions,” which every human will endure hundreds of times over a lifetime of movies, TV shows, and sporting events. I don’t hate it; it’s just not a song that I would ever listen to by choice. Its inclusion in Guitar Hero is questionable, too, given its relative lack of guitar and bass. If you’re going to map half of any song’s guitar chart to piano chords, why bother putting it in the game?
Vampire Weekend’s “Cousins” and Rise Against’s “Savior” are terrible songs by terrible bands. I actively hate them and never want to play them again.
So, really, I like one-third of Guitar Hero’s paltry tracklist. I haven’t counted how many songs I hate in Rock Band, but I think it’s safe to say that Rock Band has a much better music selection.
Read the rest of this entry »
Tags: activision, guitar hero, Music, reviews, rhythm